Reeves: Rishi Sunak’s promise to grow the economy is now in tatters
This is Rishi Sunak’s recession, declares Rachel Reeves, Labour’s Shadow Chancellor.
Reeves points out that the news that the UK is now in a technical recession will be “deeply worrying” for families and businesses.
Following the news that GDP shrank by a worse-than-expected 0.3% in October-December, Reeves says:
“Rishi Sunak’s promise to grow the economy is now in tatters.
The prime minister can no longer credibly claim that his plan is working or that he has turned the corner on more than fourteen years of economic decline under the Conservatives that has left Britain worse off. This is Rishi Sunak’s recession and the news will be deeply worrying for families and business across Britain.
It is time for a change. We need an election now to give the British people the chance to vote for a changed Labour Party that has a long-term plan for more jobs, more investment and cheaper bills. Only Labour has a plan to get Britain’s future back.”
As flagged earlier, today’s GDP report shows the UK stagnated in the second quarter of 2023, before shrinking in both Q3 and Q4.
Key events
Reeves: Britain remains trapped in a spiral of economic decline
Labour’s shadow chancellor, Rachel Reeves, is warning that Britain is trapped in a spiral of economic decline.
Giving a press conference in London now, Reeves says this morning’s drop into recession is “deeply worrying news” for families who are struggling to make ends meet, and for businesses too.
Reeves points out that today’s GDP data is provisional, and may change (the ONS regularly updates its data), but adds:
It is absolutely clear that Britain remains trapped in a spiral of economic decline.
Reeves also points out the GDP per head (a measure of living standards) fell in every quarter last year (as covered at 7.58am).
She says people didn’t need today’s GDP data to know that the economy wasn’t working. But, they “shine a spotlight” on the scale of that failure, she insists, adding:
These numbers shine a spotlight on the scale of that failure.
The confirmation of recession exposes a government and a prime minister completely out of touch with the realities on the ground.
Labour: This is Rishi’s recession
Labour are keen to pin the recession on Rishi Sunak, with a new advert contrasting the PM’s claim that the economy has “turned the corner” with this morning’s bad economic news:
EC cuts growth and inflation forecasts
Over in Brussels, the European Commission has cut its growth forecasts for this year.
The EC now expects the eurozone to only grow by 0.8% in 2024, down from an earlier forecast of 1.2%.
The wider European Union is expected to grow by 0.9%, a cut from 1.3%.
The Commission says:
After narrowly avoiding a technical recession in the second half of last year, prospects for the EU economy in the first quarter of 2024 remain weak.
However, economic activity is still expected to accelerate gradually this year. As inflation continues to abate, real wage growth and a resilient labour market should support a rebound in consumption.
This weaker growth means the EC has cut its inflation forecasts too.
Consumer price inflation, which hit 5.4% in 2023, is now expected to drop to 2.7% this year, not the 3.2% forecast in November. It is then seen slowing to 2.2% in 2025.
The EC says:
Lower-than-expected inflation outturns in recent months, lower energy commodity prices and weaker economic momentum set inflation on a steeper downward path than anticipated in the Autumn Forecast.
In the near term, however, the expiry of energy support measures across Member States and higher shipping costs following trade disruptions in the Red Sea are set to exert some upward price pressures, without derailing the process of declining inflation.
Today’s GDP report shows there was another slump in UK homebuilding at the end of last year.
Output from new construction work fell by 5.0% in the October-December quarter, including an 8% drop in private housing – the fifth quarterly drop in a row.
Repair and maintenance work grew by 4%, resulting in a 1.3% drop in overall construction output in Q4.
There’s talk this morning that the Bank of England could be pushed into raising interest rates sooner than expected, by Britain’s drop into recession.
Yesterday’s inflation report, showing prices rising slightly slower than expected, could also give the BoE some confidence to cut borrowing costs.
Joshua Mahony, chief market analyst at Scope Markets, says:
Coming hot on the heels of yesterday’s inflation report that saw both headline and core CPI move sharply lower for the month of January, we are seeing a perfect storm build that puts the Bank of England in a prime position to cut rates in the coming months.
Concerningly, we have also seen UK GDP per head continue to trend lower, with the tepid economic growth seen over recent years only coming about through an increase in the population rather than any improvement in the economy per se.
Russ Mould, investment director at AJ Bell, points out that the UK stock market was slightly higher this morning, amid recession-driven rate cut hopes.
“Confirmation that the UK is in recession has done nothing to knock UK stocks off course. An economy pushing through mud is not new news and if anything, it might encourage the Bank of England to think harder about cutting interest rates to avoid further economic deterioration.
That’s certainly how the market views the situation as UK equities ploughed ahead.”
But Craig Erlam, senior market analyst at OANDA, argues that the BoE won’t be bounced into early rate cuts by the technical recession.
The Bank of England obviously won’t be swayed by the technical recession, as Governor Bailey alluded to earlier this week, but weaker household spending may suggest demand isn’t as strong as they anticipated.
We’ll get another update on that tomorrow from the January retail sales figures.
With inflation expected to fall to target in the second quarter, maybe even further after this week’s readings, the debate around rate cuts could intensify earlier than they would have otherwise thought. Slower wage growth would obviously help that along greatly.
Charles Hepworth, investment director at GAM Investments, says Britain is now in the “slow to no growth post-Brexit” world, following its drop into recession.
He writes:
The adage of voters getting the government they deserve seems frivolous, but this is the slow to no growth post-Brexit alternate universe we find ourselves in despite prime minister Sunak’s failed pledge to grow the economy.
Today’s twin by-elections will show whether the Tories can defend their seats or whether voters really have had enough.”
Voters could point out that they haven’t had a chance to vote for Sunak at a general election yet.
The majority did, of course, plump for Brexit in 2016 – a decision which means Britain’s economy is 5% smaller than it would have been if the country had chosen to stay in the European Union, according to an analysis by Goldman Sachs this week [see Monday’s liveblog for full details].
The pound has not really been hit by the UK’s fall into recession.
Sterling is down 0.1% against the US dollar this morning, at $1.255, and a similar amount against the euro at €1.1699.
Susannah Streeter, head of money and markets at Hargreaves Lansdown, says pessimism about the UK’s prospects are weighing on the poudns.
It seems clear that national resilience in the face of higher interest rates and painful borrowing costs has finally buckled.
Even though the official recession recognition was expected, confirmation has pushed down the pound slightly, as pessimism about the UK’s prospects spreads.
UK direct debit failures jump
More bad news: the number of UK households missing their direct debit payments has jumped, as the cost of living squeeze tightens.
New data from the ONS this morning shows that the total Direct Debit failure rate rose to 1.07% in January 2024.
That is the highest level seen since the data series started in January 2019, and a 14% increase from January 2023.
There’s no reason to panic, yet, about the UK economy, argues Henry Cook, senior economist at Japanese financial services group MUFG.
Cook points out that the jobless rate remains low, at 3.8% in the last quarter – while consumer confidence has picked up:
All told, it was a disappointing set of GDP figures, but there’s no reason to panic just yet. For a start, the labour market remains firm with the unemployment rate stands at 3.8%, close to its historical low. Consumer confidence has also gradually improved over the last 18 months. That doesn’t scream ‘crisis’ to our minds. Meanwhile, it’s perfectly feasible that the ‘technical recession’ will be revised away in later national account updates.
The overall picture remains one of a stagnant UK economy with the monthly GDP estimate for December 2023 at exactly the same level as it was 12 months previously. The economy has essentially drifted sideways as monetary policy tightening and squeezed household finances have weighed on activity.
Full story: UK economy in recession as households cut spending
Richard Partington
If you’re just tuning in.. we’ve learned this morning that the UK economy fell into recession at the end of last year as hard-pressed households cut back on spending in response to soaring interest rates and rising living costs.
The Office for National Statistics said gross domestic product (GDP) fell by a larger than expected 0.3% in the three months to December after a decline in all main sectors of the economy and a collapse in retail sales in the run-up to Christmas.
It followed a drop of 0.1% in the third quarter, confirming a second consecutive quarter of falling national output – the technical definition of a recession.
Official confirmation of a recession is a blow to the government with an election less than a year away and will embarrass Rishi Sunak, after the prime minister made growing the economy one of his five priorities for government at the start of last year.
More here.
The UK’s fall into a technical recession is a blow for the Prime Minister on a day when he faces the prospect of losing two by-elections, says Ruth Gregory, deputy chief UK economist at Capital Economics.
But there are also indicators that the recession is near its end, Gregory adds:
This is clearly a blow for the Prime Minister who has pledged to “grow the economy” in 2023 (whether he is referring to growth in 2023 as a whole (0.1% y/y) or in Q4 itself is not clear). But today’s release is more politically significant than it is economically.
At the margin, it might nudge the Bank of England a little closer to cutting interest rates. But we doubt the Bank will be too worried about what is likely to be a mild and short recession. Overall, today’s release does not change much.
We still think that the economy will contract by 0.1% q/q in Q1, but that a modest recovery will take hold in the second half of this year, as inflation falls, taxes are cut and the boost from lower interest rates starts to be felt.
Analysis: Even a technical recession is a headache for Rishi Sunak
Larry Elliott
The UK’s fall into a technical recession brings to an end a miserable year for the economy, our economics editor Larry Elliott writes:
Growth in 2023 as a whole was just 0.1% – the weakest performance outside the Covid pandemic year of 2020 since 2009.
In one sense, there is no comparison between 2009 and 2023. The former was a severe recession, with output declining by about 6% over a protracted period. In 2023 the economy had essentially stagnated: growing by 0.2% in the first quarter, remaining unchanged in the second quarter and then shrinking slightly in the second half of the year.
That said, even a technical recession is a headache for Rishi Sunak, who made growing the economy one of his five new-year pledges at the start of 2023. As the shadow chancellor, Rachel Reeves, was quick to point out, the prime minister has failed to deliver on that promise.
Here’s another sign that UK living standards are in decline:
Bloomberg say:
The ONS figures revealed that on a per-person basis the UK has been in recession since the second quarter of 2022, a downturn concealed only by record migration. GDP per head has shown no growth for seven consecutive quarters, the longest period since records began in 1955.
UK and Germany bottom of G7 growth league
The UK was the joint-worst performing G7 economy in the last quarter of 2023.
The UK’s 0.3% drop in GDP in October-December was matched only by Germany, which is on the brink of recession after a 0.3% contraction in Q4.
Japan’s economy shrank by 0.1% in the last quarter, data released overnight showed.
France stagnated in Q4, while Italy grew by 0.2%.
Across the Atlantic, Canada is estimated to have grown by 0.3% in October-December, while the US was top of the pack with growth of 0.8%.
Since the pandemic, Germany is the weakest performer, followed by the UK (although this table doesn’t include Japan’s new growth figures).
Panmure Gordon’s Simon French points out that high energy costs have hit Europe and Japan more than the US.
Starmer: Rishi Sunak has failed to turn the corner on 14 years of Tory economic decline.
Keir Starmer has warned that working people will pay the price of the recession:
Economic research institute NIESR point out that UK GDP per head remains lower than before the Covid-19 pandemic (having fallen through 2023).
Jeremy Hunt has now insisted that prioritising the fight against inflation was the “right thing to do”, after the UK slid into technical recession.
The Chancellor told broadcasters:
“We always expected growth to be weaker while we prioritised tackling inflation, that means higher interest rates, and that is the right thing to do because you can’t have long-term healthy growth with high inflation.
“But also for families when there is a cost-of-living crisis, when the cost of their weekly shop is going up, their energy bills are much higher, it is the right thing to do.
“The underlying picture here is an economy that is more resilient than most people predicted, inflation is coming down, real wages have been going up now for six months.
“If we stick to our guns, independent forecasters say that by the early summer we could start to see interest rates falling and that will be a very important relief for families with mortgages.”
The money markets expect the first rate cut to come by June.